If you think old news is not worth anything, you need to spend some time on these two Bloomberg articles written by David Evans - Banks Sell ‘Toxic Waste’ CDOs to Calpers, Texas Teachers Fund and CDO Boom Masks Subprime Losses, Abetted by S&P, Moody’s, Fitch. Maybe you read them the first time around or saw some of the coverage from other media sources that referred to them. But for anyone like me that missed them when they were written about 3 weeks before Merrill Lynch and Bear Stearns made CDOs a popular headline, these articles are scary in the issues they raised then and in retrospect, the concerns they bring out now.
Like many of you, I do a lot of research and read all that I can when I know I am not informed enough. But what usually happens on “hot” news stories is that you get overwhelmed with all the different commentaries that are being written in real time. I alter my approach and look for coverage from days, weeks or months before. It’s amazing what information is freely given before the spotlight is shining and you can find critical missing pieces that don’t make it into current articles. Sometimes old news seems like a scoop.
That’s the way I felt today when I was doing research on the regulatory aspect of the CDO market and stumbled upon these articles. I want you to develop your own opinion by reading the original content from Mr. Evans, remembering that this was written almost three weeks before it became popular news. But I will bias you with this summary - there are serious questions about who was selling what to whom and with what kind of assurances about returns and risks. Maybe even more importantly, there are serious implications about who was buying what based on what kind of understanding and on behalf of whom. The fiduciary responsibilities in our business are paramount and no amount of performance chasing can supersede it. As for the ratings and regulatory issues, they are at the heart of investor confidence and quality markets. In this case, I have no confidence now.
Many of today’s articles on CDO’s are trying to provide a comforting message that things aren’t as bad as they seem. We all know that keeping calm during a crisis is important. However, I cannot comprehend how anyone can read through the Bloomberg articles and stay calm about the dangers to the markets. Pretending there is no problem is not “calm” - it’s either ignorance, intentional neglect, or worse.