By now, I am sure you have all heard Chairman Bernanke discuss the need to restore confidence in markets. Apparently, many in the government feel that the mandate of the Fed is centered on this principle and I suspect that is one of the only 100% bi-partisan sentiments you can find in this polarized mess we call democracy and free market capitalism. Certainly the financial media loves to hype every opportunity to show the government in action and more frequently, pseudo-journalists like Kudlow and Cramer love to take it one step further and call them to action. Investors seem to demand and love the idea as well - as long as they get the higher prices they think they deserve.
Of course, “restoring confidence in markets” means different things to different people. The popular view espoused by many and implemented by the President’s Wrecking Working Group on Financial Markets does not appear to match my definition of “confidence in markets.” My perception of the prevailing concept is that market declines are a reflection of a lack of confidence and when they appear, this government feels it must intervene. Of course, once the prices come back to previous highs, then by that definition the confidence is coming back. And when prices are higher…isn’t it strange that the calls for Fed intervention go away? It all sounds so simple and you would think that even a dummy like me could see the light.
However, my belief in capitalism means that there are losers. That there are risks. That taking risks can lead to rewards or believe it or not, punishment. I’d like to have “confidence” that those kinds of markets exist or can exist again. But too much has happened in the past year to make that a reality.
I enjoyed reading Ben’s October 15th speech to the Economic Club of New York (click here for the full text.) Please read the whole thing and hear his message about why the Fed has taken the numerous monetary policy actions over the past few months. In the conclusion, you’ll see a reiteration of the need to restore confidence of investors in their ability to price assets. Nice touch! Keep that slogan front and center.
Today’s reaction to another rumor of a secret emergency Fed meeting and intermeeting rate cut started a 200 point Dow rally at about 2:20pm. It was eerily similar to what happened on August 16th and given that Ben made the prior rumor come true before the August 17th opening bell, it’s no wonder that the shorts got scared and speculative longs played along. Of course, if you actually read what Ben said in that speech last week, you’ll have a tough time finding a hint of his belief in the need for a cut of any sort, discount or Fed Funds prior to the Halloween FOMC meeting(get your costume ready).
But you see, it just doesn’t matter right now. It’s too late for sanity. Prior policy decisions matched the cries of the bulls who had supposedly lost confidence in markets and were timed much too coincidentally to avoid the perception that the Fed is no longer the independent organization they need to be to maintain the foundations of confidence in markets. And that was only followed by the absurdity of Ben offering himself up as a tool of politicians like Senators Schumer and Dodd with the press conferences over special meetings and special letters all made public to “calm the markets” and apparently “restore confidence.” So today’s rumor rally should not come as a surprise.
I am confident that whoever started the rally had confidence in his markets. The kind we have now. The kind that have been “handled” by the Fed’s interventions and proposals like the Treasury’s SIV Superfund. The kind of markets that can be so easily manipulated by whispering Ben’s name, throwing in a few secret handshake gestures, mentioning a cut, etc. etc. Confidence. Confidence. Confidence.
On October 17th, I suggested that the stockonomists would call for emergency Fed cuts after a 3% decline. The S&P 500 close on that day was 1541.24 and by 2:20 this afternoon it was at 1492 - a 3.2% decline. How’s that for luck? Good guess.
If you believe the trader talk, this market moved about 1.5% on a rumor. Prices are higher. A negative close was averted. Did that inspire confidence for you?
Chairman Bernanke - restore my confidence. Take a stand on this. Do not announce your intention to comment. Just issue a press release so the anticipation of what you will say will not be further abused. Take a stand and say there will be no intermeeting cut. Show that you will no longer stand for the abuse of the Fed. Start restoring my confidence in free market capitalism. Start restoring my confidence in the non-political independence of the Fed. If the market declines on your statement, so be it. If you do nothing to show you are not willing to be manipulated, this nonsense will continue. Restore my confidence!