Using Monday’s closing prices…..of the 3,150 stocks I cover with HEDGEfolios, 95% are higher than they were at the beginning of March. The average loss was -15% with a median of -10%. The average of the winners was +110% with a median of a 66% gain.
So what!?! Given that the S&P is up 60% since the March lows, I guess those figures are not as remarkable as they should seem.
After all, from the beginning of September 2008 to the beginning of March 2009, 97% of the 3,150 stocks declined. The average and median loss were approximately -50%. The average gain was +15% with a median of +11%.
Let’s say you buy into the notion that many stocks are just getting back what they lost from last September to March when the index dropped about 45%. Maybe you believe that the credit crisis and the Lehman failure or AIG bailout or some other problem from back then unfairly whacked almost every stock to levels that were not representative of what should have been “fair.” If that were true, then I can imagine something like a stock that lost 50% from September to March and then gained 100% on the rally. And that certainly happened with quite a few stocks…about 20% of the stocks are within 10% of last year’s price. As I pointed out, about 95% of the stocks went down on average to match the index during the decline and about 95% went up with an average that mirrored the index’s rally gains.
But those are averages which happen to include quite a few extremes and I encourage you to do some analysis of your own. If you do, you’ll find about 1600 stocks in the HEDGEfolios universe that are up greater than 60% since the beginning of March and over 100 have appreciated between 400% - 3400%!
I encourage you to decide what you consider “extreme” and then try to justify it. For example, what were valuations like last fall, last spring and now? What has changed about the company or its industry relative to macro trends? Can you objectively look at the gains since March and find reasons why current prices are justified by the company’s financial prospects?
You have to decide for yourself when to buy and when to sell. And in my opinion, it rarely makes sense to sell something just because it has gone up “too far or too fast.” But if you cannot explain why a stock with declining revenues, no profits over the past year, no forecasted earnings for the coming 12 months, etc. etc. keeps heading higher at rates much faster than market gains, you better pay extra attention. Because whenever the powerful forces that are propping up such a stock decide to leave, there may be no fundamentals or technicals to prevent significant declines.
Here are a few stocks that I am watching.
AAI, ACTG, ADAT, AERT, AGEN, AMAG, AMCC, AMCS, AMSC, AN, ANAD, ARQL, ARRS, ATE
AVII, AVNR, AXL, BCRX, BKI, BONT, CADX, CAMP, CAR, CCE, CHS, CKEC, CLZR, COT
CPWM, CRAY, CROX, CS, CTB, CVTI, CWTR, CY, DDS, DECC, DIN, DITC, DNDN, DSCM
DTG, EEFT, ELGX, ELON, EPAY, EVR, EXEL, EXPE, F, FLML, FORM, GERN, GOL, GPI
GSIC, GSS, HEB, HGSI, HTZ, ICTG, IFON, IMA, IMAX, ISPH, ISTA, IVAC, JEF, KBW
KLIC, KONG, LCAPA, LCAV, LEN, LNET, LONG, LORL, LPSN, LSCC, LXRX, LZ, LZB
MDVN, MERX, MFN, MGI, MNKD, MOVE, MRNA, MU, MVIS, MXWL, NAK, NANO, NAVR, NENG
NKTR, NVAX, NVDA, NVTL, NWK, OFIX, OMTR, OPWV, OVRL, OVTI, PAG, PALM, PBY, PHH
PJC, PLAB, PMI, PROV, PTN, RAD, RDN, RDWR, RFMD, RT, RVSN, SALM, SBSA, SCON
SCSS, SEH, SFN, SGEN, SHFL, SHI, SLXP, SMOD, SMRT, SNDK, SNIC, SNS, SNTS, SPF
SPPI, SUPG, TBBK, TELK, TKS, TLAB, TQNT, TRBN, TUTR, TZOO, UBET, VCI, VECO, VICL
VIMC, VMED, VNDA, VVTV, WGO, WLK, WPP, WPTE, WSTL, XJT, ZHNE, ZRAN